Reverend Dr. Keith S Bagley joined NFBC in 2005. He advocates for lifelong learning and seeks to "rightly divide the Word" in his teaching at New Fellowship. Rev. Keith has earned two doctorate degrees: a Doctor of Ministry (D.Min.) with a focus on Transformational Leadership from Rockbridge Seminary, and  a Ph.D. in Computer Science from the University of Massachusetts. Rev. Dr. Keith was ordained by NFBC's founding Pastor (Bertha Perkins) in 2015 and is also a member of the Board of Trustees for the American Baptist Churches of Vermont and New Hampshire (ABC-VNH).

Minister Bobbie D. Bagley joined NFBC in 2004. She is one of the four ministers covering Sunday Services and teaches Wednesday Night Bible Study. She has been a minister and teacher of the gospel for 35 years with street ministry and international missions experience. 

In addition to their leadership roles at NFBC,  Keith and Bobbie are also pastors of one of New Fellowship's sister ministries - The Blueprint Ministries (also an ABC-VNH affiliate).  Keith is also an honorary bishop at Jesus Victory Centre in Nairobi, Kenya.